Dolly Parton Wrote 'I Will Always Love You' For Porter Wagoner, Why Did He Sue Her For USD 3 Mil?

Dolly Parton passed away at the age of 80, leaving the entertainment industry heartbroken. Amid her demise, her relationship with Porter Wagoner has once again made headlines.

By Juhi Sharma Last Updated: Aug 26, 2026 | 06:34:02 IST

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add BollywoodShaadis on Google
ADVT.

Dolly Parton's death at the age of 80 has come as a shock to everyone. The musician was immensely loved in and outside of the entertainment industry, and that is evident in the tributes that have poured in since the news of her passing was announced. For those who are not aware, Dolly passed away on Tuesday, August 25, 2026 (ET), after a brief battle with cancer.

ADVERTISEMENT

Amid Dolly's demise, her fans are returning to the stories behind some of her biggest songs, including the track often heard as a romantic breakup ballad. Yes, we are talking about I Will Always Love You. However, did you know Dolly Parton actually penned the song while preparing to leave her working partnership with Porter Wagoner? Let's take a look at their relationship and the story behind the hit.

Meet Porter Wagoner, the man who helped Dolly Parton become a well-known name in the music industry

Dolly Parton often described Porter Wagoner as her mentor, producer, and duet partner. While nothing romantic was ever confirmed between the two, their close bond often fueled tabloid speculation. According to The Washington Post, neither ever said there was anything romantic between them, and Dolly was married to Carl Dean throughout the years she worked for Porter.

ADVERTISEMENT.

While Dolly Parton was still making her place in the entertainment world, Porter Wagoner was already an established country singer, a television host, and a Grand Ole Opry member when he invited a 21-year-old Dolly to join The Porter Wagoner Show in 1967. For those who don't know, Porter had hired Dolly as a replacement for singer Norma Jean in the cast. Dolly had already released her debut album and was starting to gain attention for her song Dumb Blonde. 

ADVERTISEMENT

While Porter Wagoner didn't discover her, his "nationally syndicated show" gave her much wider exposure. The Country Music Hall of Fame says the program reached nearly 100 markets and more than three million viewers. They also became a major recording duo, scoring 14 Top 10 country hits together, while he worked as the producer-arranger on their duet albums and supervised much of her RCA solo output during that period. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Dolly Parton's exit and the lawsuit

Dolly Parton always planned to build a career of her own, and she cited the same as the reason for her exit from Porter Wagoner's show. The country singer, in an interview with PBS and PEOPLE, said that while she initially agreed to a five-year contract, she stayed on The Porter Wagoner Show for seven years.

Continue reading below

She reflected on how her solo records and songwriting career were still growing, and she wanted to have more creative freedom. However, Porter was worried that Dolly's exit would hurt his show. Dolly Parton recalled how "Porter had a real hard time after other people started recording" her songs. She stated:

"I was writing, and I was getting to be pretty popular. And it was his show. I wasn't trying to hog it. But I just kind of carved out a little, you know, place for myself. But it was a love-hate relationship. We fought like cats and dogs. We were just both very passionate people. There was no way that I wasn't going to do what I was going to do. And no way I was going to not do what he thought I was going to do."

ADVERTISEMENT

After repeated conversations, Dolly and Porter still could not agree on her exit, which led Dolly Parton to write I Will Always Love You. The singer performed the song in Porter's office, expressing her gratitude while also making it clear that she was leaving. According to Dolly's official account, Porter cried and called it "the best thing" she "ever wrote," then agreed to her exit on the condition that he could produce the records. 

However, whether he produced it or not remains unclear, as Bob Ferguson is listed as the official producer. Dolly left the show in 1974, and I Will Always Love You reached No. 1 on the country chart that year, long before Whitney Houston turned it into a global pop hit for The Bodyguard. Nonetheless, their separation didn't end their business dispute. Five years after Dolly's exit, Porter filed a breach-of-contract lawsuit against Dolly in 1979.

The lawsuit sought a share of Dolly Parton's income and royalties. Porter reportedly sued her for USD 3 million. The case was settled out of court a year later in 1980, with Dolly reportedly paying approximately USD 1 million in installments over several years. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Did Porter Wagoner and Dolly Parton ever patch things up?

Despite the heated feud, Dolly Parton and Porter Wagoner eventually reconciled. The latter once reflected on their patch-up and said that Dolly even performed I Will Always Love You for Porter during his 50th Opry anniversary celebration in May 2007, their final appearance together on that stage. Porter, who died from lung cancer in October 2007, called Dolly "one of my best friends today" at the Ole Opry celebration. She also visited him while he was hospitalized.

What are your thoughts on Dolly Parton's relationship with Porter Wagoner? Let us know.

ADVERTISEMENT

Next Read: Dolly Parton Revealed 'Hardest Part' Of Living Alone After Husband Carl Dean's Death, 'The Loss..'

ADVT.
ADVT.
Chitrangda Singh's Glam Looks
18 December, 2023
ADVT.
ADVT.