Martin Short Cut Selena Gomez's Wedding Cake Before Her First Slice, 'He Looked Like A Little Dog'

'The Only Murders in the Building' stars recently recalled some fun moments they shared during Selena Gomez's wedding to Benny Blanco in September 2025.

By Saakshi Gupta Last Updated: Nov 21, 2026 | 06:02:23 IST

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add BollywoodShaadis on Google
ADVT.

Selena Gomez and Martin Short recently recalled an unexpected moment from her wedding to Benny Blanco. Interestingly, Martin Short accidentally cut into the couple's wedding cake before they could have their first slice. In turn, it left the guests shocked and the actor embarrassed. They shared more details about the incident during their latest appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live! on November 19, 2026.

ADVERTISEMENT

How did Martin Short accidentally cut Selena Gomez's wedding cake? 

Martin Short explained that he had assumed the small cakes placed near the different guest seating areas at Selena's wedding were kept for everyone to enjoy. In fact, he saw a particularly tempting cake near the section where he was seated with Selena and some other co-stars. So, when Steve Martin seemed ready to leave the event early, Martin insisted that he must try the cake before leaving. 

ADVERTISEMENT.

In turn, Martin then cut into it twice with a fork without knowing that he had just sliced into the actual wedding cake. He realized his mistake when people began to shout his name, "Marty!" After realizing his mistake, Martin turned to Paul Rudd and jokingly suggested that they leave. Meanwhile, he tried to hide the incident from reaching Selena and even tried to cover up the damage with his fork. 

However, the secret did not stay hidden for long. Someone eventually went to the bride and whispered, "Marty cut your cake." The singer recalled that when she went to confront him, Martin looked "like a little dog with his tail between his legs."

ADVERTISEMENT

She then told him, "I heard you ate my cake." The duo then looked at a photo of the damaged cake during the interview, and Selena joked about the visible fork marks. Still, she clarified that she was not upset and would always be grateful that he tried to fix it. In her words:

"We will always have that memory together, and honestly I'll never forget it."

ADVERTISEMENT

For those who don't know, Selena Gomez and Martin Short share a close friendship that developed while they were working on Hulu's Only Murders in the Building. Martin, Steve Martin and Selena form the central trio of the comedy-mystery series.

Continue reading below

They play the role of neighbors who become involved in solving murders while hosting their own true-crime podcast. Despite their significant age difference, the actors share a strong and affectionate bond off-screen.

The trio's chemistry was apparently there from the beginning. During their first Zoom table read for the series, Martin and Steve were impressed by Selena's comedic timing and professionalism. They reportedly called each other later to talk about her performance.

ADVERTISEMENT

Over the years, the three have continued to share a playful dynamic. In fact, Selena often joins in on the jokes rather than simply being the target of them. 

More about Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco's wedding 

Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco tied the knot on September 27, 2025. Their private wedding celebration took place at Sea Crest Nursery, a palm tree farm in Santa Barbara, California. The wedding was planned by wedding planner Mindy Weiss and reflected the couple's desire for a relaxed and personal gathering rather than a traditional, formal wedding.

Selena and Benny wore custom Ralph Lauren outfits. The actress wore a floral-embellished halter-neck gown for the ceremony before changing into a tea-length dress for the reception. Overall, the wedding was attended by nearly 170 guests. It included Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, Paris Hilton, Paul Rudd, and many of Selena's co-stars. Rapper and actor Lil Dicky officiated the ceremony, and Steve Martin was the ring bearer. 

ADVERTISEMENT

What do you think about Martin Short mistakenly eating Selena Gomez's wedding cake before she had her first slice?

Next Read: Pete Davidson Is 'Casually Dating' Brooks Nader's Sister Sarah Jane, Still Seeing Other People

ADVT.
ADVT.
Chitrangda Singh's Glam Looks
18 December, 2023
ADVT.
ADVT.